Five Years Later, Part 3: A Buy and Sell List for the Last Five Rookie Classes
Decile 1 and 2 DMX rookies, 2022 to 2026 · November 18, 2026
I published this during week 11 of the 2026 season, so the ranks and reads below are through week 10. The Rookie Screener will change from here. I update it every week through the season, and in the years to come.
In two recent articles I went through decile 1 and decile 2 DMX rookies from 2001 to 2021 to see who hit and what the early signs looked like. Here they are if you missed them: 244 Top Prospects, Five Years Later and Decile 2 Rookies, Five Years Later. The question I got was, OK, so what do I do with my roster right now? So, I took the rules from those two pieces and ran every decile 1 and 2 rookie from the 2022 to 2026 classes through them.
Quick refresher if you haven’t read through one of these articles yet. DMX is the prospect score I built from draft capital, athletic testing and age-adjusted college production. You can read how it works here. Deciles 1 and 2 are the top 20% of each class. A hit means the same thing as before: at least one starter season, top 12 for QB and TE, top 30 for RB and WR, PPR scoring.
How I scored them
There are 128 decile 1 and 2 skill players in those five classes. 40 of them have already hit, so these rules don’t tell you anything new about them. They’re listed at the end so you can check my work. That leaves 88 who haven’t hit yet, and that’s where this gets interesting. You can see all 128 on the Rookie Screener, which updates every Tuesday through the season.
Each of the 88 gets the one rule from the articles that fits where he is in his career, plus the historical hit rate that goes with it. Players drafted in 2022 have had four seasons, so I look at how often a player with no hit after four years got one in year five. The 2023 class has had three seasons, which is the rule behind the 9% for decile 1 receivers. The 2024 class gets the same test after two seasons. For the 2025 class it’s where he finished as a rookie, compared only with players who also didn’t hit as rookies. And for the 2026 rookies it’s their share of the team’s touches or targets so far, compared with rookies at the same position.
My rule of thumb: 60% or better is a buy or hold, 30% to 59% is one to watch, and under 30% is a sell or drop. If fewer than 15 players in the history fit the rule, I don’t make a call, because that’s not enough to lean on. That takes Cam Ward, Jaxson Dart, Mason Taylor, Fernando Mendoza and Ty Simpson off the board for now. And to be fair, it’s too early to call for all of them.
The guys beating the odds
Base rates tell you what usually happens, and every year a few players don’t care. Seven players who haven’t hit yet are inside the hit line so far this season:
| Player | Drafted | Before 2026 | 2026 so far | History says |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Christian Watson | 2022, D1 WR | WR41, WR68, WR76, WR46 | WR4 | 0 of 42 hit in year 5 |
| Isaiah Likely | 2022, D2 TE | TE27, TE25, TE16, TE45 | TE2 | 1 of 36 |
| Matthew Golden | 2025, D1 WR | WR88 | WR6 | 34% |
| Omarion Hampton | 2025, D1 RB | RB35 | RB28 | 59% |
| Luther Burden | 2025, D2 WR | WR49 | WR15 | 67% |
| Bhayshul Tuten | 2025, D2 RB | RB53 | RB15 | 56% |
| Cam Skattebo | 2025, D2 RB | RB37 | RB22 | 56% |
Watson is the one that jumps off the page. Since 2001, zero of 42 decile 1 receivers who went four years without a hit got one in year five. Zero! He’s WR4 right now. History can’t tell you much about what comes next, because nobody in the sample has done this. What it does tell me is I wouldn’t pay a WR4 price to go get him. If you have him, enjoy the ride, and listen if someone offers you that price. Likely is the same story at tight end. Burden is obviously breaking out and is a keeper, as is Tuten. The Giants shopped for a running back at the deadline and pulled out of a Jonathan Taylor deal, so they’re not sold on him. Skattebo answered with 27 points in week 10, but holding him is still a risk, and you may want to sell while he’s hot. Then again, as Bruce Arians said, “No risk it, no biscuit.”
Omarion Hampton finished RB35 as a rookie. Decile 1 backs who finished between RB31 and RB60 without a hit went on to hit 13 of 22 times (59%). That’s right on the edge of a buy, and he’s RB28 this year, inside the line. He’s a solid hold at this point, he’s not producing elite numbers but you’re not going to get your investment back from him at this price, so give him time and this offense a chance to evolve in a year or two.
Sell or drop
These are the players the numbers are hardest on, worst odds first:
| Group | Players | History says |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 D1 WRs, no hit in 4 seasons | Skyy Moore, Treylon Burks, Tyquan Thornton, Jahan Dotson | 0 of 42 |
| 2022 D2 QB, no QB1 season in 4 years | Kenny Pickett | 0 of 18 |
| D2 TEs, no hit in 3+ seasons | Daniel Bellinger, Jelani Woods, Brenton Strange, Darnell Washington, Luke Musgrave, Luke Schoonmaker | 1 of 36 |
| D2 WRs, no hit in 3+ seasons | Calvin Austin III, John Metchie, Tank Dell, Josh Downs, Marvin Mims | 6% to 10% |
| 2023 D1 WRs, no hit in 3 seasons | Quentin Johnston, Jonathan Mingo, Jalin Hyatt | 9% |
| D2 RBs, no hit yet (2022 to 2024 classes) | Tyrion Davis-Price, Kendre Miller, Tyjae Spears, Israel Abanikanda, Jaylen Wright, Trey Benson | 10% to 25% |
| 2023 D1 QBs, no QB1 season in 3 years | Bryce Young, Anthony Richardson | 12% |
| 2024 D2 TEs, no hit in 2 seasons | Theo Johnson, Ja’Tavion Sanders, Tip Reiman | 12% |
| 2025 D2 TE, rookie finish TE60 | Elijah Arroyo | 17% |
| 2024 D1 QB, no QB1 season in 2 years | J.J. McCarthy | 18% |
| 2024 D2 WRs, no hit in 2 seasons | Troy Franklin, Ja’Lynn Polk, Malachi Corley | 21% |
| 2025 D2 WRs, rookie finish outside the top 60 | Jaylin Noel, Pat Bryant, Jack Bech, Tai Felton | 24% |
| 2022 D1 TE, no hit in 4 seasons | Greg Dulcich | 24% |
| 2024 D1 WRs, no hit in 2 seasons | Rome Odunze, Keon Coleman, Xavier Worthy, Xavier Legette, Adonai Mitchell, Ricky Pearsall | 29% |
First I’d say this about the list, some of these are obvious. We know Kenny Pickett is not a starting quality QB, that Treylon Burks is a role-playing depth receiver and Tyrion Davis-Price is not going to come back to the NFL and light it up. But there are interesting plays on the edge of this information.
For example, eight receivers on this list also carry the injury flag from the first article, nine or more weeks on IR or reserve in their first three seasons: Treylon Burks, Skyy Moore, Tyquan Thornton, Calvin Austin III, John Metchie, Tank Dell, Ricky Pearsall and Ja’Lynn Polk. Decile 1 receivers with that history hit 24% of the time. Decile 2, just 10%. Yuck. That said, Tank Dell just had a great game in week 9 (followed by a dud in week 10), so he’s one to watch. For me, I think the writing is on the wall for the rest of these guys. They could be bench stashes for depth, but if you have the opportunity to get more production elsewhere, or to trade these guys for future picks, now may be the time.
Brenton Strange (TE19 this year) and Josh Downs (WR32) are playing well enough right now that you won’t have to give them away. I’d still be looking to move Strange. He is what he is at this point. Only 1 of 36 decile 2 tight ends found a hit after year three, and I don’t want to be the one paying for that lottery ticket. And Downs to KC may well have saved his career, you can’t possibly sell now with Patrick Mahomes throwing to him, he’s likely the best receiver they have now, certainly better than anyone not named Rice.
The 2024 decile 1 receivers are the real decision. 29% isn’t zero. With six of them, history says one or two hit. Rome Odunze is the closest, WR41 last year and WR35 this year. My take: these are sells while the market still prices them like first-round picks, and I wouldn’t drop any of them. If you have strong conviction, keep them. But beware, most don’t hit, so don’t let roster bias get you.
Also, man the odds are stacked against J.J. McCarthy, aren’t they? I have him in one league and I’m still holding onto him to see how he does this year, but I may lose his value if I wait too long.
Players to watch
Michael Mayer is the interesting one. He’s TE13 this year, one spot off the line, and decile 1 tight ends without a hit through three years still got one 35% of the time (7 of 20). That’s the “be patient with decile 1 tight ends” rule from the first article in action.
The rest of the watch list: Ben Sinnott (57%), Dylan Sampson (56%), Terrance Ferguson (50%), Jonathon Brooks (40%), Travis Hunter (34%, scored as a receiver), Michael Penix Jr. (33%) and Kaleb Johnson (32%). All of these have had varied success and could still hit if they can stay healthy. Ben Sinnott is an interesting one, popped on the score sheet in week 10, after doing next to nothing in his first two-plus seasons. One week doesn’t a trend make, but certainly worth keeping an eye on.
Buy or hold
Jayden Higgins is the one buy outside this year’s class. Decile 1 receivers who finished between WR31 and WR60 as rookies, without hitting, went on to hit 78% of the time (18 of 23). He comes with one asterisk: he already has nine weeks on IR or reserve, which is the injury flag above.
For the 2026 rookies, the early read is their share of the team’s touches or targets so far. Rookies in the top third for their position hit a LOT:
| Player | Pos | Decile | 2026 so far | History says |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kenyon Sadiq | TE | D1 | TE28 | 94% |
| Carnell Tate | WR | D1 | WR46 | 91% |
| Makai Lemon | WR | D1 | WR47 | 91% |
| KC Concepcion | WR | D1 | WR27 | 91% |
| Denzel Boston | WR | D2 | WR24 | 79% |
| Germie Bernard | WR | D2 | WR55 | 79% |
| Jeremiyah Love | RB | D1 | RB43 | 71% (middle third) |
On the other side, three decile 2 rookie receivers are in the bottom third for target share: Zavion Thomas, DeZhaun Stribling and Chris Brazzell II. Historically, 1 of 33 decile 2 receivers in that spot hit. Decile 2 tight ends Max Klare, Oscar Delp and Marlin Klein are in the same spot (12%). Jordyn Tyson is the decile 1 name to keep an eye on. He’s in the bottom third too, and decile 1 receivers there hit 34% of the time. Now that he’s back on the field, early indications are that he may be just fine going forward. The rest of this year’s class sits in between. Jadarian Price and Mike Washington Jr. (48%), Eli Raridon (47%), Eli Stowers and Sam Roush (44%) are ones to watch, and Omar Cooper and Ted Hurst (26%) lean toward a sell.
Bottom line
Base rates are a starting point. They don’t know about a trade or a new coordinator and so forth, and the 2026 numbers are only part of a season. But when 0 of 42 or 1 of 36 is staring at you, you’d better have a really good reason to keep paying for the dream. The screener keeps this current every week, and I’ll write it up again after the season wraps up, I hope it helps you with your decision making. Happy hunting!
The 40 who already hit
These players already have at least one starter season, so the rules above don’t apply to them. First hit is the season of his career and where he finished.
| Player | Pos | Drafted | Decile | First hit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C.J. Stroud | QB | 2023 | D1 | Year 1, QB9 |
| Bo Nix | QB | 2024 | D1 | Year 1, QB7 |
| Caleb Williams | QB | 2024 | D1 | Year 2, QB5 |
| Drake Maye | QB | 2024 | D2 | Year 2, QB2 |
| Jayden Daniels | QB | 2024 | D1 | Year 1, QB5 |
| Breece Hall | RB | 2022 | D1 | Year 2, RB2 |
| James Cook | RB | 2022 | D2 | Year 2, RB12 |
| Kenneth Walker III | RB | 2022 | D1 | Year 1, RB18 |
| Rachaad White | RB | 2022 | D2 | Year 2, RB4 |
| Bijan Robinson | RB | 2023 | D1 | Year 1, RB9 |
| Devon Achane | RB | 2023 | D2 | Year 1, RB24 |
| Jahmyr Gibbs | RB | 2023 | D1 | Year 1, RB10 |
| Zach Charbonnet | RB | 2023 | D2 | Year 2, RB25 |
| Ashton Jeanty | RB | 2025 | D1 | Year 1, RB11 |
| Quinshon Judkins | RB | 2025 | D1 | Year 1, RB26 |
| R.J. Harvey | RB | 2025 | D2 | Year 1, RB20 |
| Treveyon Henderson | RB | 2025 | D2 | Year 1, RB21 |
| Trey McBride | TE | 2022 | D1 | Year 2, TE7 |
| Dalton Kincaid | TE | 2023 | D1 | Year 1, TE11 |
| Sam LaPorta | TE | 2023 | D1 | Year 1, TE1 |
| Brock Bowers | TE | 2024 | D1 | Year 1, TE1 |
| Colston Loveland | TE | 2025 | D1 | Year 1, TE12 |
| Harold Fannin | TE | 2025 | D1 | Year 1, TE6 |
| Tyler Warren | TE | 2025 | D1 | Year 1, TE4 |
| Alec Pierce | WR | 2022 | D2 | Year 4, WR28 |
| Chris Olave | WR | 2022 | D2 | Year 1, WR25 |
| Drake London | WR | 2022 | D1 | Year 3, WR5 |
| Garrett Wilson | WR | 2022 | D1 | Year 1, WR21 |
| Jameson Williams | WR | 2022 | D1 | Year 3, WR22 |
| Wan'Dale Robinson | WR | 2022 | D1 | Year 4, WR14 |
| Jaxon Smith-Njigba | WR | 2023 | D1 | Year 2, WR9 |
| Jordan Addison | WR | 2023 | D2 | Year 1, WR23 |
| Rashee Rice | WR | 2023 | D2 | Year 1, WR27 |
| Zay Flowers | WR | 2023 | D1 | Year 1, WR30 |
| Brian Thomas Jr. | WR | 2024 | D1 | Year 1, WR4 |
| Ladd McConkey | WR | 2024 | D2 | Year 1, WR12 |
| Malik Nabers | WR | 2024 | D1 | Year 1, WR6 |
| Marvin Harrison Jr. | WR | 2024 | D1 | Year 1, WR30 |
| Emeka Egbuka | WR | 2025 | D1 | Year 1, WR23 |
| Tetairoa McMillan | WR | 2025 | D1 | Year 1, WR15 |