Career Tiers: Elite Peak to No Startable Season

Data Dictionary · how NFL career outcomes are classified

Career tiers are how I sort NFL careers across the whole platform, four ways: Elite Peak, Starter Peak, Flex Peak and No Startable Season. Every drafted prospect with a completed career window gets one, and it comes from a single number: his best NFL season. These are the outcome labels the DMX model gets trained on and tested against. A hit, everywhere on this site, is an Elite Peak or a Starter Peak.

The four tiers — and the base rates

Here's how careers actually shook out across every offensive prospect from the 2001 through 2020 draft classes with a finished career window (n = 2,032):

TierShareNWhat it means
Elite Peak16.4%333At least one season among the best at his position
Starter Peak16.3%331His best year was a season you would start every week
Flex Peak21.0%427His best year was flex or bye-week fill-in
No Startable Season46.3%942Never once had a season worth a lineup spot

Offensive prospects, draft classes 2001–2020, career tier labeled. Live counts from the public database.

Look at that last row, because it's the whole story: nearly half of all drafted skill guys never have a startable season, and only about one in three ever has a Starter Peak or better. That's the backdrop for every rookie pick you'll ever make. The question isn't “will this guy hit?” It's “does anything about this profile beat a coin flip that's rigged 2-to-1 against me?” That's the whole reason to score prospects at all — to move you off that base rate. The top DMX decile hits at 79.1%; the bottom sits at 7.0% (full table in the DMX guide).

How tiers are assigned

There's no opinion in these tiers. I take a player's best NFL season in PPR points and hold it against a fixed line for his position: 300 for an Elite Peak at quarterback, 200 for a Starter Peak and 100 for a Flex Peak; 200, 120 and 50 at running back and receiver; 150, 75 and 30 at tight end. Nobody's voting. A guy two percent under the Starter line gets a Flex Peak even if his career “feels” like more. Yeah, that's a little arbitrary right at the boundaries, and I say so.

Read the label for what it is. It's his best year, not his whole career. One big season is an Elite Peak whether he backed it up or not, so a guy who had one monster year and faded sits in the same tier as a guy who did it for a decade. I tested a stricter rule that asks for three good seasons, and it sorts the deciles even more sharply. I kept the best-season rule because it's the one every published number on this site was built on. The label says peak so nobody mistakes it for a career.

Why the model predicts tiers, not points

Here's something the validation makes clear: predicting the tier works about twice as well as predicting exact fantasy points (tier R² of 0.289–0.415 across positions, versus 0.102–0.207 for exact VBD — all twelve regressions are in the whitepaper). Careers clump into types a lot more cleanly than they line up on exact point totals. Guessing which kind of career a guy gets is just a more learnable problem than nailing his point total to the decimal, and for dynasty, it's the more useful answer anyway.

Where you'll see tiers

The Draft Board puts each historical prospect's actual outcome tier right next to his DMX score — that's the model's track record, out in the open, class by class. The Analytics page uses the tiers for residual analysis: the Elite Peaks I scored too low and the no-startable-season guys I scored too high sit on ranked leaderboards, not buried where you can't find them.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of drafted NFL skill players bust?

In the 2001-2020 draft classes with finished career windows, 46.3% of offensive skill prospects (942 of 2,033) never had a startable season. Only about 33% had a Starter Peak or better.

What counts as an Elite Peak?

A best season of at least 300 PPR points at quarterback, 200 at running back or receiver, or 150 at tight end. About one drafted skill player in six gets there. The lines are fixed, not anybody's opinion, and one season is enough.

Are career tiers subjective?

No. They come from fixed lines on a player's best season at his position. The boundaries are a little arbitrary — a guy just under a line gets the lower tier — and the label only tells you how high his best season went.

Can a player's tier change?

A tier rests on a player's best season, so it can only move up, and only for a player still in the league. The hit rates use the 2001-2020 classes, which have all had at least five seasons. Recent classes don't have a tier yet — for them, DPX tracks where their dynasty value is right now.